THE2014LINE

Chapter 12 · 6 of 15

The Farm

Record harvests, a missed promise, three laws, a 13-month siege — and the era's only full surrender.

The farmRetreat

Before → after

Foodgrain production

Before265.05 MT2013–14
After357.73 MT2024–25 record

Wheat MSP per quintal

Before₹1,4002013–14
After₹2,5852026–27 season

Farmers who sell at MSP

Before~6%2015 committee
After21 lakhwheat sellers, 2025–26, 5 states

Farm household income / month

Before₹8,0592016–17
After₹12,6982021–22 · ~flat in real terms

Farm-sector suicides

Before12,3602014
After10,5462024 · labourers now ~56%

Protest deaths, 2020–21

Before~700union count
After'no record'government, in Parliament
The doubling promise: growth needed vs history, % a year
Needed to double by 2022
10.4 %/yr
Historical rate
3.7 %/yr

The government's own committee did this maths in 2016.

What a legal MSP guarantee costs — two different questions, ₹ crore a year
'Buy everything' scenario
10,00,000 ₹ cr
Gap-payment model (CRISIL data)
21,000 ₹ cr

The gap model is ~2% of the scare figure — and a seventh of the 2019 corporate tax cut's yearly cost.

Foodgrain production, million tonnes
2013–14
265.05 MT
2024–25
357.73 MT

Rice and wheat at all-time highs.

One person, before and after

  1. 1

    Balwinder's grandfather grows the new wheat. The state buys it.

  2. 2

    Water 300 ft down. ₹8 lakh in debt.

  3. 3

    At 52, he drives a trolley to Delhi's border.

  4. 4

    Home after 13 months. The laws are dead.

  5. 5

    Farmers stopped at Khanauri. Again.

Before 2014

After 2014

The promise

2× by 2022farm income target, set 2016
  • Needed 10.4% growth a year.
  • History managed 3.7%.
  • The deadline passed in silence.

Which 'cost'?

A2+FL vs C2the formula fight
  • Govt counts cash + family labour.
  • Farmers add land rent and interest.
  • Gap: thousands of rupees an acre.

Three laws (2020)

Voice votehow they passed the Rajya Sabha
  • Sell anywhere, outside the mandi.
  • Company contracts; disputes go to officials.
  • Stock limits mostly lifted.
  • No farmer union consulted.

The siege

13 monthscamped at Delhi's borders
  • Singhu, Tikri, Ghazipur.
  • Lakhimpur Kheri: 8 dead.
  • ~700 deaths (union count).
  • Govt in Parliament: 'no record'.

The retreat

19 Nov 2021the PM announces repeal
  • The era's only full policy surrender.
  • MSP committee: 4 years, no report.
  • 2024: tear gas dropped from drones.

The scoreboard

357.7 MTrecord foodgrain
  • Record farm exports: $51.9 bn.
  • Income ₹8,059 → ₹12,698/month — flat after inflation.
  • 10,000+ farm suicides a year.

Still fighting about

1

Good laws, bad politics?

Government's case
  • Economists backed mandi reform.
  • MSP was never abolished.
  • Middlemen fuelled the protest.
Critics' case
  • Small farmer vs corporation, no court.
  • If the mandi dies, MSP dies.
  • Bihar tried it. Farmers lost.

The book: Reform without consent fails. Consent is the load-bearing wall.

Where do you lean?

2

Should MSP be a legal right?

Government's case
  • Could cost ₹10 lakh crore a year.
  • Could worsen the water crisis.
Critics' case
  • Gap-payment model: ~₹21,000 crore.
  • A seventh of the yearly corporate tax cut.

The book: Two numbers answering two different questions.

Where do you lean?

3

Whose crisis is it?

Government's case
  • Suicides and debt predate 2014.
  • Record output and buying.
Critics' case
  • Promised to double income, then went silent.
  • Passed the laws without asking farmers.

The book: 46% of workers share under a fifth of income. Every era's shame.

Where do you lean?

The verdict

The farm

RetreatRule 3
Strongest verified FOR

Record 357.7 MT foodgrain; record procurement spend

Strongest verified AGAINST

Income-doubling promise missed and unmentioned; the laws repealed; >10,000 farm suicides a year

Yours

The book gives none. Slide; it is saved to your scoreboard on this device.

Clearly worseWorseNo real changeBetterClearly better

Your full scoreboard →Timeline for this sector →Quiz →
Read the full chapter — the book’s own words

Loading…

The farmer's son leaves the farm and finds — what, exactly? The most fought-over numbers in India: Chapter 13, Work.